How to Choose an Executor or Trustee

Free Consultation
small hero section image
Choosing an Executor

Selecting the right person to administer your estate or manage your trust is one of the most important decisions in estate planning. The executor of your will (called a personal representative in Florida) and the trustee of your trust carry significant legal responsibilities and will have considerable authority over your assets and the well-being of your beneficiaries. Choosing someone who is trustworthy, capable, and willing to serve ensures your estate plan is carried out according to your wishes. An Orlando, FL estate planning lawyer can help you evaluate potential candidates and structure your documents to provide appropriate oversight.

The Role of a Personal Representative in Florida

In Florida, the person who administers a deceased person’s estate through the probate process is called a personal representative rather than an executor. The personal representative is appointed by the court after being nominated in the decedent’s will and has numerous duties under Florida Statutes Chapter 733.

The personal representative must identify and collect the decedent’s assets, which may involve searching for accounts, securing real property, and valuing business interests. They must notify creditors and pay valid claims against the estate, file the decedent’s final income tax return and any estate tax returns, and distribute the remaining assets to beneficiaries according to the will.

Throughout the estate administration process, the personal representative has a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the estate and its beneficiaries. They must keep accurate records, provide accountings to beneficiaries, and avoid self-dealing or conflicts of interest. A personal representative who fails to meet these obligations may be removed by the court and held personally liable for losses to the estate.

Florida Qualifications for Personal Representatives

Florida law establishes specific qualifications for who may serve as a personal representative. Under Florida Statutes Section 733.303, the following individuals are disqualified from serving:

Anyone who has been convicted of a felony is disqualified. Anyone who is mentally or physically incapable of performing the duties is disqualified. Anyone under the age of 18 is disqualified.

Non-residents face additional restrictions. A non-resident may serve as personal representative only if they are related to the decedent by blood, marriage, or adoption. This means your best friend who lives in another state cannot serve as your personal representative, no matter how capable they may be.

Florida residents may serve regardless of their relationship to you. Banks and trust companies authorized to exercise fiduciary powers in Florida may also serve as personal representatives.

The Role of a Trustee

A trustee manages assets held in a trust according to the terms established by the grantor. During the grantor’s lifetime, a revocable living trust is often managed by the grantor themselves as initial trustee. When the grantor dies or becomes incapacitated, the successor trustee takes over.

The trustee’s responsibilities include managing and investing trust assets prudently, making distributions to beneficiaries according to the trust terms, keeping beneficiaries reasonably informed about the trust, maintaining accurate records, and filing trust tax returns when required.

Unlike a personal representative whose role ends when the estate is closed, a trustee may serve for years or even decades if the trust continues for the benefit of minor children, individuals with special needs, or future generations. This longer time horizon makes selecting the right trustee even more critical.

Florida trustees are governed by the Florida Trust Code, which establishes detailed duties and standards of conduct. Working with an Orlando, FL trust lawyer helps ensure your trust includes appropriate provisions for trustee authority, compensation, and succession.

Qualities to Look for in a Fiduciary

Whether you are selecting a personal representative or trustee, certain qualities are essential for effective service.

Trustworthiness is paramount. Your fiduciary will have access to significant assets and broad authority over your affairs. You need someone whose integrity is beyond question and who will always act in the best interests of your beneficiaries.

Financial responsibility matters. Look for someone who manages their own finances well, understands basic investment concepts, and can work with attorneys, accountants, and financial advisors when needed.

Organizational skills help ensure nothing falls through the cracks. Estate administration and trust management involve tracking numerous deadlines, maintaining records, and coordinating with multiple parties.

Availability and willingness are practical considerations. Serving as a fiduciary requires a significant time commitment, especially during the initial months of estate administration. Make sure your chosen person has the capacity to take on this responsibility and genuinely wants to serve.

Impartiality may be important if your beneficiaries have competing interests. Blended families often benefit from a neutral fiduciary who can balance the needs of a surviving spouse against the interests of children from a prior relationship.

Longevity is relevant for trustees who may serve for many years. A trustee who is significantly older than your beneficiaries may not be able to serve for the full duration of the trust.

Individual vs. Corporate Fiduciaries

You may choose an individual, such as a family member or trusted friend, or a corporate fiduciary, such as a bank or trust company.

Individual fiduciaries often have closer relationships with beneficiaries and a deeper understanding of family dynamics. They may serve without compensation or for modest fees, and they can bring personal knowledge of your values and intentions. However, individuals may lack investment expertise, may become incapacitated themselves, and may have conflicts with other family members.

Corporate fiduciaries provide professional management, investment expertise, and perpetual existence. They are regulated, bonded, and have established procedures for handling fiduciary responsibilities. However, corporate fiduciaries charge ongoing fees that can be substantial, may feel impersonal to beneficiaries, and may not understand your family’s unique circumstances as well as an individual would.

Some families use a combination, naming an individual and a corporate co-trustee to balance personal attention with professional management. Others name an individual as primary fiduciary with a corporate successor if the individual cannot serve.

Naming Successors

Always name at least one successor personal representative and successor trustee in your documents. If your first choice cannot serve due to death, incapacity, or unwillingness, your successor steps in without the need for court intervention.

Consider naming multiple levels of successors, particularly for trusts that may last for many years. Your documents can also include a mechanism for selecting a new fiduciary if all named successors are unavailable, such as giving beneficiaries the power to appoint a successor or designating a process for selection.

Having the Conversation

Before naming someone as your personal representative or trustee, have a candid conversation with them. Explain what the role involves, discuss the time commitment, and make sure they are genuinely willing to serve. Some people feel honored to be asked but are not actually prepared to take on the responsibility.

This conversation also gives you an opportunity to share your values, explain your decisions, and provide context that will help your fiduciary carry out your wishes effectively. An Orlando, FL living trust lawyer can help prepare materials that guide your fiduciary through the administration process.

Choose Your Fiduciaries Thoughtfully

The people you choose to manage your estate and trusts will have a profound impact on how smoothly your estate plan operates and how well your beneficiaries are served. Take time to consider your options carefully.

Magill Law Offices helps Orlando families select appropriate fiduciaries and create estate planning documents that provide clear guidance for those who will serve.

To discuss your estate planning needs, contact Magill Law Offices to schedule a free consultation.

← Back to Estate Planning Resources